Map: 
Locations: 18
Black Horse Tavern (1720–1740s)

Bar (ghost), 36–40 Exchange Place

Show on map

Bluebell Tavern (c1725–1915)

Bar (ghost), approx. Broadway and 181st St, NW corner

Show on map

Bull’s Head Tavern (c1750–1813)

Bar (ghost), approximate location of the original Bull’s Head, near the entrance to the Bowery

Show on map

City Tavern/New Amsterdam City Hall (c1640s–1790)

Other (ghost), NW corner of Coentis and Pearl

Show on map

Day’s Tavern (c1770s–c1780s)

Bar (ghost), approx. St. Nicholas and 126th St

Show on map

De La Montagnie’s Tavern (1770s–c1790s)

Bar (ghost), 253 Broadway

Show on map

Fraunces Tavern (1762–)

Restaurant (extant), 54 Pearl St

Show on map

Horse & Cart (1690s–????)

Bar (ghost), 122 William St

Show on map

James Matthews’ Tavern (c1670–1688)

Bar (ghost), NW corner of Broad and Pearl

Show on map

James Webb’s St. George & the Dragon (c1665–????)

Bar (ghost), 211 Pearl St

Show on map

John Hutchin’s Coffee House/King’s Arms (1696–????)

Bar (ghost), site of Trinity Builiding, facing churchyard

Show on map

Litschoe’s Tavern (1640s–????)

Bar (ghost), approx. 125 Pearl St

Show on map

Merchant’s Coffee House, Tontine Coffee House (1738–1826)

Other (ghost), NW corner of Water and Wall

Show on map

Province Arms/New York Arms (1754–1794)

Bar (ghost), Broadway between present day Thames and Cedar

Show on map

Royal Oak (1676–????)

Bar (ghost), 44 Broadway

Show on map

Thompson’s Crown & Thistle (1750s–c1760s)

Bar (ghost), Whitehall Slip

Show on map

West India Company Brewery (1620s–1660s)

Other (ghost), north side of Bridge St between Broad and Whitehall

Show on map

Wooden Horse/White Horse Tavern (1641–c1650s)

Bar (ghost), NW corner of Whitehall and Stone

Show on map

>